Characters for my comic

  • @reddprime Cool! It's fun to see these different ideas. What's the story behind this character? That might help a bit in terms of giving feedback. Is he a straight up stylized fish? Or some kind of mutant fish man? His arms and legs in the 3 on the right make me think of wood right now. Not that that's a problem, but that's an association that's coming up for me.

  • I like the far left one best … might be the pose, but he seems like a bad ass πŸ™‚ What is Finn's back story? Is he a bad ass? I'm guessing from the Ninja head strap thingy that he might be a fighter? πŸ™‚

  • Thanks for the feedback, extremely helpful.
    Some background on the character. He is a normal pet store goldfish, who gets bought and taken home to discover that his fishbowl is a portal to another dimension.
    Here is discovers that the region that he lands up in is being ruled by a cruel crimelord Kingfin (might change but liked the play on Kingpin), who is an octopus. He is trained by an old koi in order to take down Kingfin...

    That is a very basic explanation of the story, all of the sudden it seems a lot less original.

  • The limbs on 2-4 are better long-term for movement/expressions, I think. I like that you're keeping the original dorsal fin. Are you keeping the scarred/missing eye?

  • Here are a few more characters. Kingfin, one of his henchmen. Then Finn and his best mate 0_1544641949888_Fish-tails.jpg

  • I have finally finished the first page to Fishtales.

    Let me know what you think, it looks extremely different from the images above, I wanted to origin section to be grayscale with some colour.


  • @reddprime I think my favorite designs here are the most left and most right. The octopus just speaks of all kinds of potential with dynamic expressions and poses like a cartoon villain, which I think sounds fun. The character to the right seems like a chill laid back kind comedic of character. Plus, I like the color schemes of both, they pop out.

  • @rinovarka Thank you. Yeah, the octopus is going to be so much fun to use for expressions, also going to have him change colours depending on the mood he is in.

  • @reddprime I'm wondering why the shark has their tail fin but the other fish character's tail fins have evolved into legs? In any case, looking good 😊

  • @laura this is a good point! I had not even given that any thought... I will have a look at what the shark looks like without a tail πŸ™‚ thanks for pointing that out.

  • Happy Monday everyone!
    I have almost completed the third page of FishTails. From page 3 one they will all be on my site:

    I do need some suggestions on how to make some female characters.


  • Finished up page 3 about a week ago, this one was a challenge. I was never happy with the illusion of movement that I needed for the claw slash.

    Please let me know what you think. I am about to start the next page.


  • Hi there! I like what you're doing, the characters have really nice designs.

    With your third page, I'm not sure if I completely understand what's happening. The first panel looks like he's scared by something coming towards him, but the words seem to state he's already been hit once. Could it work to have a small panel first showing something coming towards him, maybe in silhouette above him or something, then what was the first panel as his reaction to seeing this thing above him, then the slash. I think one hit works just as well if not better.

    Also, I'm assuming he's evolved by going through the portal? As I was reading about your character design at the top of the post, I was wondering if that might be how he becomes more anthropomorphic.

    EDIT: I just re-read it, and realised the pain he's experiencing first is his evolving, right?

  • Maybe it would help with the transition from the second to third page if you show the swirl from the portal in the background behind the face of the main character? It wouldn't necessarily need to be in any of the others--but still maybe include it as small and disappearing behind the fish character in the second panel (for story flow)? Hope that makes sense.
    Keep up the good work! You're doing great. πŸ™‚ πŸ‘πŸ»

  • SVS OG

    @reddprime probably late in the process but I don’t think your main character should be called Finn if the villain is named Kingfin (although I appreciate the pun).

  • @reddprime Another reader late to the party...
    I'm really liking where this is going. Once you started posting your characters and panes in color, they really took off. I think your scenes really take off in page 2 and 3. Could you show more of the story with less narrative boxes on the first page. Tricky-but I think it would draw me in more quickly.

    I'm not sure what the "blue light" is-but maybe I don't need to know yet, maybe that's part of the hook to draw us in.

    The large image on the 2nd page looks a little out of color-could the goldfish (Finn?) have more warmth and even a little orange/gold while he's in shadow, to tie the images together?

    And I don't think the 3rd page needs the dialog at all-I think your images tell the story.

    Keep posting! I want to see what happens.

  • @avfarrar This makes total sense! Thanks for the input, it makes more sense than the green light I was using πŸ™‚

  • @BenBernardSmith Hey! Thanks for the feedback. So the plan is to create some confusion in this panel, why does he look different in from here on in that he did in the previous pages? I want the audience to experience the confusing Finn was experiencing as this unfolded, but it gets explained soon.

  • @reddprime I can see you want us to experience the confusion he's feeling, but I would say that I initially thought that the first pain he was feeling was caused by him being hit, so if you want readers to know more clearly the two pains are different, you might want to show that somehow, but still keep some of the confusion. Clarity is important when a story begins or the audience can be turned away.

    But up to you! Just some thoughts. Keep up the good work! πŸ˜„ I look forward to seeing more!

  • Hi all, I have been struggling with the next page, I have started and been on it for a few weeks, which feels like an eternity.
    So page 4 has Finn waking up after being knocked out. We see the top of the cave he is in, then he sees two characters starting at him. From there, I want to show him sitting up all confused and then, a close-up shot of him trying to figure out what has just happened, how did he go from a fish in a tank, to a fish being attacked, waking up in a cave with these two new characters around him.

    I would really appreciate some advice on how to illustrate and portray this, please.


Log in to reply