July image, need your thoughts on cropping

[lmrush]

To crop or not to crop, what are your thoughts?
[poll title="July image; Crop verses not to crop" maxvotes="1" end="1564416000000"]

[/poll]

[MichaelaH]

@lmrush Like the bottom one, without crop

[lou]

@lmrush I like the cropped version...but both work!

[MichaelaH]

What about croping it only from bottom and right?

[juliekitzes]

I like the uncropped version. The boat gets lost and becomes unnoticeable when you crop it in my opinion.

[djly]

I agree with @MichaelaH - there seems to be some dead space at the bottom right but like the composition of the full character on the left.

[jwing]

I like the uncropped version, I think it gives a better sense of setting/depth and keeps the boat in more focus.

[lmrush]

@MichaelaH Like this????

[MichaelaH]

@lmrush looks better, I personally would not crop the wing

[lmrush]

@djly Like this???

[lmrush]

Thank you everybody!!!!!!!!! Looks like the uncropped version wins, thank you for your time.