Carrying out a second fall idea and looking for critique


  • SVS OG

    Take 2! Actually 4, because there are two versions I never posted 😝. Still need to loosen up the sausages and of course work out a lot of details including consistent shadows for the dog, and either that's a small girl or a big Jack Russell, but want to make sure I'm heading in the right direction first. What do you guys think? Is this an improvement over the previous version?

    0_1540042466965_Nina dogs and sausages 4a.jpg


  • SVS OG

    @sas And I forgot to address the foot angle fully. Will gave that some thought next!



  • @lauraa I really love how you have reworked the image. There is a lot of great movement and life to it. The gesture on the dog is really cute!


  • SVS OG

    And a quick fix, because my daughter pointed out that if the dog is biting the sausages, they're going to be taut. Still have to work out the details, though...

    ...who knew that illustration would require working out the physics of sausages?!

    0_1540044634690_Nina dogs and sausages 4b.jpg


  • SVS OG

    @burvantill If I go back to that version, I'll work it out. The original idea was that the arm was bent in, and thus foreshortened, but if that isn't evident, it means I didn't draw something right!


  • SVS OG

    @lauraa I like this version a lot and kudos to your daughter for catching the physics of pulling on sausages!


  • SVS OG

    Thank you for your patience and help guys--I'm uploading yet another version! Something about those taut sausages was attracting too much attention for me, so I worked out a version with the dog jumping at, but not reaching, the sausages.

    The sausages are tighter and jumbly-er, but in my research on the physics of flying link sausage (a limited field indeed) the string of sausages always curves a bit and acts as a whole.

    I also decided that the POV is low enough to the ground that perhaps we really can see under her boot.

    Any other critiques you'd like to make before I move on?

    Boy, is it ever going to be satisfying to move on to color and texture on this thing! But I think that in the process, I am learning to draw much better from my imagination. And that's kind of the point, isn't it? 😊

    Thanks so much for your help!

    0_1540219269217_Nina and sausages 5.jpg


  • SVS OG

    @lauraa You can see the dog's face better in this version too. I can't wait to see it colored!



  • @lauraa really like the updated version! The movement is more dynamic, can’t wait to see color


  • SVS OG

    Color studies! Below I have posted three basic schemes at the top with white backgrounds, and then variations on each labelled 1, 2 or 3 plus a letter. Because I had one left over and have little time, I'm posting a final choice below as a separate .jpeg. Its number is 3f. Pardon the sloppiness of the layout but knowing my working time was coming to an end for the day, I wanted to get this in today for some feedback. Your feedback is valuable to me!

    BTW, I checked all of these in B & W, but I admit I have a weakness for similar values of red and green vibrating off one another, so I left some pretty close. Is that a deal breaker? What do you guys think?

    Looking forward to getting your opinions! Knowing I have way too many choices, I tried to make it as easy as possible to compare. Thank you so much!

    0_1540904690211_Color study gamma.jpg
    0_1540904923909_Nina and sausages color studies 3f.jpg


  • SVS OG

    Since posting, I have gone back and redrawn the figure, redesigned things, etc. As you can see, I haven't redone the shading on everything yet, but I am really struggling with taking this thing to finish, so I thought I'd post again since I have to take a break now anyway. Am I missing something fundamental here? Especially something about the whole composition and pose? This is the part I struggle the most with in my process, and I wonder if it's because I'm missing something crucial at an earlier stage. Thoughts?

    Added: I guess an additional question is, given that I've gotten so far away from my thumbnail and original sketch, maybe there' s something going wrong with my thumbnail or sketching stage?!

    0_1542969714650_Nina and sausages new.jpg



  • Hi Laura, I am very impressed by how you well you've improved the image from the first sketch to the final colored version. The relation between the dog and the girl is much more dynamic, it works also better without the scarf. However I wonder why you changed the hand holding the sausages and the space between the dog and the girl?


  • SVS OG

    @Julia I changed the hand because there was something really awkward in that arm, and I finally decided it might be that the running pose necessitated that the arm be in more of a typical running position. But there's still something about it that doesn't convince me. That's one reason I posted!

    The space was because the figures looked a little lost in the white space to me, so I made the girl bigger. But then that necessitated bringing the dog closer. Also, it might make it look more like he's about to get a sausage!



  • @lauraa To me, the other arm worked better because I imagined she was suddenly holding the sausages higher, which in turn made the dog jump. With the other arm, there is more distance to cover and the sausages are probably too heavy to fly over the shoulder with this type of curve (unless she runs very very fast in a strong wind!). I would be interested to know what the others think as I am by no mean an expert in composition and in motion πŸ˜‰ Good work though, the dog and the girl really work well together.



  • @lauraa if you read/buy the book Understanding the Invisble Art of Comics by Scott McCloud, there is a whole chapter on time frames - It's a comic about sequential art. In there is a section on action lines from those used in Europe through to the US and then onto Japanese influences. This is a great help for creating motion and the understanding the illusion of motion in a static image. Worth a read. On the front cover there's a quote by Neil Gaiman "You must read this book." So I bought it.


  • SVS OG

    @julia I tried the arm up version again with the other changes I'd made and it just felt all out of balance to me. So here's a version with the other arm down. What do you think?

    0_1543064412992_nina and sausages new arm up.jpg


  • SVS OG

    @sigross I looked up this book, and it seems it's something of a phenomenon. I may have to order it! Thanks!



  • @lauraa it looks better to me! but if it doesn't look right to you, then don't listen to me πŸ™‚ Let's see what others think!



  • @lauraa It definitely is. I'd have learnt a lot more in school, if all textbooks were written in comic book form. The illustration is coming together well. Can I make a suggestion for the dog - if he is moving to keep up with the girl in full stride with his tongue out then I think his mouth would be wider open. With the tongue flapping further up the side of his face. Like a scarf in the wind. Or a flapping string of sausages! Maybe even showing him licking his top lip a bit as he smells those sausages.


  • SVS OG

    I thought this might help someone. I did silhouette studies all week. It was a busy week with a lot of tech support, so I kept having to walk away from the silhouette, and when I'd come back to it, it was fresh and so I'd make changes. I think it's a lot better now--it was way too top heavy before!

    You can see the progression inside the boxes outlined in red, and then the first and last versions with the arm down at the upper right. I also made notes on what changed each time. It was time consuming, but I really want to learn from my mistakes.

    Now, the trick is, how do I learn to spot these things earlier and save myself some time and a lot of agonizing?! I keep posting updates on this piece because I'm really trying to work through my process and how I can improve it. I hope it might help someone else as well. As usual, suggestions welcome!

    @sigross Though you can't see the change here because I kept pasting the same dog, I did move the dog's head up, and when I start redrawing I will also look at the position of his mouth and tongue.

    0_1543663196730_N and S silhouette changes.jpg


Log in to reply