8 Aug 2017, 17:01

@mallette Hi Mallette,

I hope you have a great time at your first SCBWI meeting!

Here are a few thoughts:

  1. You're probably going to be told that your work looks "commercial", "slick", or something to the effect of "too beautiful for children's books." What they are trying to express is that your work looks like the kind of art that's used on the back of cereal boxes, on games, cards, puzzles, etc. Most of the editors that will speak or that might review your portfolio are looking for a unique style - something they haven't seen before. This will come over time and @Lee-White is going to be presenting a 3rd Thursday dedicated to style. Your work looks like a lot of work out there - but don't worry because the longer you work the more your own personal style will emerge...but it does take time, dedication, and hard work.

  2. Your portfolio ventures into the fantasy, children's, and YA book cover markets. It's going to be hard for an editor to have the confidence to hire you based on what you currently have because you're not demonstrating enough of one market. 10 pieces is a good rule of thumb to be able to present to an art buyer on just one of those areas. I really like the kids running from the Haunted house - but it's not backed up by more YA book cover looking art.

I really hope this helps. Please understand that I think you're well on your way - it just takes a lot of hard work and time!

Cheers,
Will