What do you think of this value/color?

[Melissa_Bailey]

@Kristen-Lango agreeing with @Asyas_illos and @carlianne -- it seems like it might be your values, not necessarily your use of color. It's great that you're not afraid of color and love saturated color. Understanding values will help you control all that color and learn how to lead the eye where you want it to go.

While most illustrators do tend to use a limited palette or a more muted palette than you do, there are working illustrators who use bright, bold, saturated colors. They also control that color, using warms and cools to create focal points, and make full use of a range of values. Bold, saturated colors aren't just midtones -- they also come in lighter values and darker values.

Here are some examples by (L to R, top to bottom) Benji Davies, James Dean, Lois Ehlert, David Catrow, Jay Fleck, Micha Archer, and Jay Fleck again:

And here is the same grouping in black and white. Even with color removed, there is a focal point in each of these illustrations. That's because of shape, composition, and value.

All this is to say... if you want to explore a wide range of color, saturated and more muted colors, go for it! If you want to stick with your bright, bold colors, go for it! Value is the key.

[carlianne]

I totally agree with @Melissa_Bailey and @Asyas_illos

I think a better question to ask is, do YOU like using bright colors? Do you like illustration styles that use muted color pallets?

If you want to do black and white images to practice controlling your values I think that would be super smart, but I'd hate to see you shift away from what appears to be something you love.

If I were in your position I would focus on controlling the color rather than getting rid of it all together. For example using a split complimentary color palette, so the colors are still unified, and you can use the warm colors as your focal point and the cool colors to recede in the background. Will's Magic of Color class would be a super super great one for you to do!

[Sarah VanDam]

@Kristen-Lango I know I was one of the people that pushed you to reconsider how you go about using color, but those are some great points by @Asyas_illos and @Melissa_Bailey

[carlianne]

I think this is your art - so here's a quick example of what I mean.

[Kristen Lango]

@Melissa_Bailey Thank you for this Melissa! I think you're totally right about value being the problem.

I love all those books and illustrators that you included! You're totally right about using bright colors but limiting the palette and making warms and cools work for you to guide the eye - that's definitely something I'm trying to get better at as well!

Thanks again for this great feedback

[Kristen Lango]

@carlianne Totally great question! I think I do like using bright color and I do like books that use them too.

But I often feel like I just don't know how to control it well.

Aw thanks! I appreciate that! Definitely, I agree with you, learning to control it seems to be the key

Ah yes that split complimentary idea is fantastic! I've seen Will do that, I will definitely try to make a piece using that technique.

Thank you!!

[Kristen Lango]

@carlianne Yep that's me! haha oh my goodness thank you for this! Yes you guys are so right about learning more about how to make value work for me.

This piece you did the draw over on is one of those that really frustrated me regarding color and I can totally see the difference in just making those sides darker.

Thank you Carlianne!

[Melissa_Bailey]

@Kristen-Lango you're so welcome! Glad it was helpful!

[Melissa_Bailey]

@Kristen-Lango here's another example of how you can use value to create a focal point with your punchy colors. This one makes it more of a nighttime scene -- not sure if that's what you were going for -- creating the focal point by making the rabbit the lightest value and the warmest color, and placing it against its complementary color for contrast:

Here it is in black and white:

Since I also work tradtionally, @AngelinaKizz recommendation to get a value window is great -- I don't use one and probably should! What currently I do is scan/take a picture of my work in progress and then change the picture to black and white to check my values. Whatever works, right?

[skeletortoise]

@Kristen-Lango I would pick 2 because I think it shows the inside vs outside well using dark for inside and bright for outside.

I do think the green character could be a little brighter to make them stand out from the background. You could even use the outside light cast on the character to bring them out.

I also think the colors go best together in 2.

[Kristen Lango]

@Melissa_Bailey Oh that's really nice too! Thank you Melissa!

[Kristen Lango]

@skeletortoise thanks for your feedback!

Here's an update on how this piece is going:

This is just my lazy way of showing this on the thread haha screenshotting my own story. But you can see more here

Thanks again guys!

[skeletortoise]

@Kristen-Lango Wow, I think it's come a long way! I think the light coming in is a great way of showing the intrusion of the kid above. Very whimsical and fun; could see on a book cover!

[Kristen Lango]

@skeletortoise Aw thank you so much!

Here's the final scan!