December (Star Wars) Contest Winner
Jake Parker last edited by Jake Parker
Hi everyone! Lee launched the contest last month, but due to a conflict of schedule handed the judging over to me. I love Star Wars, so I couldn't say no. You creative people have done some amazing work! Made it really hard to pick a winner.
Here's my judging criteria:
Concept - Is the idea creative or unexpected in an intriguing way?
Design - How has the artist used proportion, repetition, balance, and contrast to create something unique, compelling, or beautiful?
Structure - Are the shapes and forms solidly built?
Rendering - Whether it's in color, black & white, or just line-work, what is the quality of the craftsmanship in the execution of the artists vision?
Okay, the artist that I felt got high marks on each of these criteria is....
1st Place @Naters-Calderone!
I felt like it was a brilliant move to place something edgy and sci-fi within the context of something as gushy and approachable as the rubber hose animation style from the 20s and 30s. (Example here)
So points awarded for concept. The design, structure and rendering on this is all solid as well. You got the style down, but you also brought a little something of your own to it. So great job!
2nd Place @Hannah-England!
Hannah wasn't the only one to turn star wars characters into animals, or dogs for that matter. But I like her concept the best. She stuck with droids, and since droids are mostly companions to humanoids in Star Wars she likened them to dogs. Nice move. Not only that, she picked dogs that best matched each droids personality or temperament. LAstly, it's just executed so darn well. Nice rendering, structure, and design. Good job Hannah!
Ha! Pretty funny. Nice idea Jason. Points for concept, but felt like the rendering and structure were lacking.
These look like they could be characters in the Star Wars Rebels series. I like where it's going, but the togrutian looking female looks so much like Ashoka that I couldn't see what you really brought to the character. I love the droid though!
Really well drawn and rendered. Great concept too!
I'm a sucker for Labrynth. Had to spot light this. Great idea, and really nice character designs. Watercolors got a little dull though. Could've used Photoshop to punch things up more.
Creative idea. Love the puns.
Another great idea, and utterly unique direction to go. Character designs got a little flat. But there's a lot of potential here. Would love to read a fan-fic of this.
More dogs! I love them. Amazing rendering on these guys.
Dude, creepy! Such a neat take on star wars. And the black and white just adds to the mystery of these designs.
All right, thanks to everyone who participated! So much talent here on this little forum. Can't wait to see what you guys deliver next month!
smceccarelli last edited by
Congratulations to all, and particularly to @Naters-Calderone!
I really loved your submission - I think they should do a cartoon with those characters!
Lee White last edited by
Great Everyone! Nice work!
sheri_p79 last edited by
Congratulations guys, they all look great!
Marsha Kay Ottum Owen last edited by
Congratulations all. @Naters-Calderone I am so happy you won. Love your submission! Everyone elses are impressive too.
Pamela Fraley last edited by
@Naters-Calderone Congratulations! Your piece was so well executed! My husband and I admired it for quite a while. ☺️
Jonas Zavacky last edited by
Congratulations everybody! :D great works
jasondmcintosh last edited by
YES! I was totally impressed with the submission by @Naters-Calderone and was secretly hoping for victory there! So cool! Great contest. Learned a great deal and it helped me spend time with my son, too!
Jason Bowen last edited by
Thanks for the honorable mention @Jake-Parker your my new favourite svs instructor 😃
Andy Gray last edited by
well done guys. bring on the next one!
umutdulger last edited by
Congratulations everyone :)
Naters Calderone last edited by
Thanks everyone, I really enjoyed this prompt and all the creativity that people put into it. I often checked the feed to see what the new submissions. and thanks to @Jake-Parker for taking the time to give us critiques and provide links to examples of vintage toons.